Friday 23 February 2007

User review websites for handyman/maintenance services

Why haven't consumer review sites for home services worked very well in the UK? Remember back in the dot-com boom there were two big-ish players, HomePro and Improveline.com. Improveline is now a fairly ordinary maintenance company, doing mainly insurance-repair work, and seems to have dispensed entirely with their tradesman-rating service. And HomePro is still around, but I don't hear anyone talking about it. Alexa gives them a rank of 1.2m, well lower than our own 800k rank, so doesn't look like that many people are visiting them either. And a quick browse through some of their listings show that each company only has a handful of ratings, i.e. only a handful of their customers have taken the trouble to log on and rate them.

You'd think this sort of thing would work. Home maintenance services (plumbers, electricians, roofers, handymen, etc.) are notoriously hard to source. By far the best source is a recommendation, so you'd think that a website devoted to recommendations would work really well in this industry. Yet for some reason they have all found it very hard to reach critical mass (of both tradespeople and consumers to do the reviewing). Here are some others;

Judgesmart.com
Workbidder.co.uk
ApprovedTradesmen.com
Bello
WantedPronto
checkatrade
Ask4Quote (gone bust)
Quote4Me (gone bust)

Check-a-trade has probably done the best in this sector, but they are still relatively tiny and rely heavily (I think) on a printed flyer listing tradesmen, rather than on people visiting the website. So they do best in areas where they have been distributing that flyer for several years - hard to roll that out nationally. But this should work as an internet-only service, you shouldn't have to be printing hundreds of thousands of advertising cards to get noticed.

Lots of these guys are trying to do two things: allow potential customers to post "projects" for tradespeople to bid on, and also provide a rating system for those customers to rate the tradesman who did the project. But I think the whole bidding on projects thing just adds too much complexity, for both the customer and the tradesman. If the project is complex enough to "bid" on, it needs a visit first, so not much point using the web to manage the "bid", just give the customer a written quote. And if it is not that big / complex, then there is not point "bidding" on it (I mean, we are hardly going to bid on "fix my leaking tap").

So what you need is just a listing of tradesmen, with a really simple feedback system, just like eBay. I suppose the huge difference with eBay is that, on eBay, both buyers and sellers want feedback, so they give it in the hope that their opposite party reciprocates. Buyers want feedback to show credibility (some auctions are restricted to buyers with certain ratings), and of course buyers are also sometimes sellers. Not the same for tradesmen/householders. The tradesman needs feedback, but there is not a huge incentive for the householder to give it. They probably only use a tradesman once a year or so, so it is not a big part of their life.

If a householder was a regular consumer of maintenance services, it would be in their interest to get feedback from tradesmen ("This customer keeps appointments, listens to my advice, and pays promptly"), but, as I say, most householders would only need a tradesman once a year or so, so don't really need to build up a good reputation as a purchaser of maintenance services. And therefore the incentive that exists on eBay (of offering feedback in the expectation of receiving valuable feedback in return) doesn't really exist with the tradesman / householder relationship.

So how do you encourage householders to offer feedback?

You can ask them nicely, of course, which is pretty effective - about 20% of our customers return our feedback cards, and we are very grateful that they do. We give a monthly prize to the handyman with the best overall feedback score, to encourage the handymen to ask their customers fill out the card. But to get our customers to report to some kind of centralised feedback website would be harder, especially as the majority of our customers would not have heard of check-a-trade or whatever.

What might work would be this: offer some kind of "feedback module" which any company could tag onto their website. That company's customers use it to offer feedback about their experience with that company. All white-labelled, so it integrates nicely with the existing website. Company gets to display and publicise that information on their website (pretty much as we do now, except a bit more sophisticated).

But if you have a load of companies using the same, standard, feedback module, you can then aggregate and share the information on a central website.

Big advantage of this is that you can much more quickly compile critical mass of feedback data, and that is the key to getting people to come to the central website, listing your approved tradespeople.

The drawback of, say, Check-a-Trade's model is that you are only really going to gather feedback from customers who found us via Check-a-trade, and even then only a proportion of those customers will take the time to offer feedback. Which is why you'll only find a handful of ratings for each company listed. But thousands and thousands of our own customers have fed back directly to us. Imagine if we, and other like-minded companies, submitted that data to a central website. That's exactly what we could do if we were all using a standardised set of questions and a standard method of collecting the data (and, of course, we'd have to tell the feedersback that their responses would appear on the central website as well as our own).

Needs a bit more thought, but there could be something in this.

33 comments:

Miranda said...

Hello Bruce

I just found your Blog, really interesting read - I 100% agree with what you are saying about Yell.com and review websites.

I run a website www.jugglefrogs.co.uk and would love to talk to you about it as I think I might have a solution but would be really interested to discuss it further with you and see what you think.

Speak soon

Miranda

miranda@jugglefrogs.co.uk

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

The best place for finding a skilled job is www.Skilled-Jobs.com

Has a section coming on tradesman and featured tradesman also.

Scott Paterson

Scott.Paterson@Skilled-Jobs.com

Anonymous said...

I used www.wolley.co.uk last month. I like the catch with their name. The guys who did my kitchen were fantastic. I guess because there is a way to spoil their future business if they mess up. I got 7 quotes in the end I went for the second cheapest which was a lot cheaper than what my nearest plasterer quoted me. Mostly because they are free of charge for the tradesmen I guess.

London Handyman said...

I Agree with your point of view. Yes! it becomes hard at times for the service providers to make a reach to the target consumers. But, more you spread your words, more you get into the eyes of others.

acting auditions said...

Hi, just dropping by to say i really like your blog, keep up the good work.

Anonymous said...

best place for getting work is building a website. lancaster builder

Unknown said...

User reviews are very important and helpful tool before selecting a handyman service providing company. Users have an experience of hiring their services and can share their experience.
Best Handyman in southeast London

Emergency Plumber in London said...

Reputation is what matter the most!
You need to be the best tradesman and provide the best service than you don't have to worry about reviews and success. It will come automaticly

Unknown said...

Nice post and I want professional handyman services in London.

xumeiqing said...

151218meiqing
nike air max
kate spade handbags
ugg boots
louis vuitton handbags
gucci handbags
michael kors bag
cheap toms shoes
coach factory outlet
concords 11
michaek kors outlet
kobe bryant shoes
vans shoes
michael kors outlet
hollister co
ugg boots clearance
ray ban sunglasses
nike air force 1
nike free run
christian louboutin outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
canada goose jackets
ugg boots
louis vuitton outlet
pandora jewelry
michael kors outlet stores
nike running shoes
polo ralph lauren
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots for men
chanel handbags
mont blanc pens
marc jacobs
celine
louis vuitton handbags
nike trainers
coach outlet
true religion jeans
cheap oakleys
coach outlet

Unknown said...

zhengjx20160601
vans sneakers
coach outlet store online clearances
toms shoes outlet online
vans outlet
longchamp outlet
coach outlet
louis vuitton outlet online
true religion outlet
louis vuitton
coach outlet
ladies cartier watches
louis vuitton handbags
rolex watches
true religion jeans
michael kors outlet clearance
christian louboutin sale clearance
ray ban sunglasses outlet
insanity workout
retro 11
rolex watches
jordan retro 11
beats by dre outlet
louis vuitton outlet
kate spade outlet
coach outlet online
louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet
adidas superstar shoes
ralph lauren outlet
fitflops
retro jordans 13
cheap oakley sunglasses
coach outlet
replica watches
longchamp handbags
louis vuitton outlet stores
coach outlet online
air jordan 4
tods outlet store
oakley canada

Unknown said...

fitflops clearance
michael kors outlet online
coach outlet store
michael kors outlet
mont blanc outlet
michael kors factory outlet
adidas uk
fitflops sale
cheap soccer jerseys
cheap oakley sunglasses
cheap mlb jerseys
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
ugg outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
christian louboutin outlet
ugg outlet online
new balance shoes
ray ban sunglasses
toms shoes
ugg uk outlet
canada goose outlet store
tiffany jewellery
hermes outlet
beats by dre
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet
rolex watches
christian louboutin shoes
juicy couture outlet
michael kors handbags
true religion outlet
chrome hearts eyewear
longchamp outlet
longchamp handbags
0808jianxiang

Unknown said...

christian louboutin outlet
ferragamo outlet
louis vuitton outlet online
cheap jordans
jordan shoes
oakley sunglasses cheap
cheap basketball shoes
polo ralph lauren outlet
ugg australia
converse outlet
cartier love ring
kate spade handbags
michael kors outlet store
louboutin outlet
michael kors outlet online
moncler outlet
burberry outlet canada
ugg pas cher
ralph lauren uk
gucci outlet online
hollister kids
christian louboutin sale
pandora charms sale clearance
kate spade bags
nike cortez shoes
coach outlet store
bottega veneta sale
ugg boots australia
fitflops shoes
ugg sale 2016
coach outlet online
uggs outlet
yeezy boost 350
pandora charms
discount oakley sunglasses
cheap air max
2061826caiyan

Unknown said...

gucci outlet
oakley sunglasses
ralph lauren outlet
nike flyknit
longchamp outlet
christian louboutin
ugg boots
louboutin uk
jordan shoes
ugg australia
2016919caiyan

Unknown said...

fitflops outlet sale
nike air max 90
christian louboutin shoes
beats by dre
tory burch outlet
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
oakley sunglasses
cazal outlet
20161116caihuali

marko said...

Presently, it is critical to comprehend that in the event that you are searching for a lodging advance or a development advance for your home, everything comes down to the bank constraining that advance. usapaydayloanstore.com/chicago

Unknown said...

cheap oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton
fitflops
christian louboutin
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses uk
michael kors outlet clearance
tods outlet
swarovski jewelry
20170327lck

Unknown said...

cheap nhl jerseys
christian louboutin
asics,asics israel,asics shoes,asics running shoes,asics israel,asics gel,asics running,asics gel nimbus,asics gel kayano
adidas nmd runner
beats headphones
iphone case uk
cheap jordans
coach outlet online coach factory outlet
coach outlet canada
pandora outlet
20170401caihuali

jeje said...

ed hardy clothing
polo ralph lauren
bears jerseys
skechers shoes
ray ban sunglasses
nike shoes
superdry clothing
adidas yeezy
san diego chargers jerseys
0416jeje

Unknown said...

qzz0424
valentino outlet
nike shoes outlet
adidas yeezy
mulberry handbags
coach outlet store online
christian louboutin
dsquared clothing
coach outlet store online
air max 90
rushe run uk

Unknown said...

dsquared2
golden goose shoes
jordan shoes
nhl jerseys
moncler jackets
pandora jewelry
nike requin
vibram fivefingers shoes
ray ban sunglasses
coach factory outlet
zzzzz2018.7.3

Unknown said...

calvin klein outlet
vibram fivefingers
michael kors
nike cortez
100% real jordans for cheap
golden goose
adidas stan smith
nike polo
nike huarache
d rose shoes

QQQQQQQQQ said...

adidas tubular shadow
nike air huarache
westbrook shoes
longchamp bags
golden goose outlet
birkin bag
louboutin shoes uk
air max
nhl jerseys
longchamp handbags

miki said...

0815jejeL'économie difficile s'est asics gel lyte 3 femme chausport avérée difficile pour de nombreuses entreprises Stockport, et même des entreprises asics gel kinsei 4 soldes à travers le Grand Manchester. Nike Shox R3-R4 de nike air jordan 11 retro low concord tous réputés ainsi que dans la demande des Asics Gel Kayano Evo Pas Cher noms de marque des clients et de les offrir asics gel lyte 3 femme grise et rose à des frais peu coûteux. Les petites entreprises nike air jordan 13 retro femme fournissent des baskets athlétiques pour diverses actions d'athlétisme new balance lille adresse comme le baseball, le soccer, le tennis, le basketball, air jordan 1 retro mid wb hare le golf, le soccer, la natation et ainsi de suite.

James jones said...

well, i would say that infertility can be a thing of the past because of modern advancements in medicine” Roswell Handyman

Unknown said...

moncler
jordan 13
pureboost
off white hoodie
converse outlet
crazy explosive
russell westbrook shoes
kate spade handbags
calvin klein outlet
adidas stan smith men

CR Custom Services HVAC/R said...

Maintenance services are required for the Commercial refrigeration repair, wine cooler maintenance, Air Conditionaer Repair for the fresh products and for the proper storage.

Codeex home maintenance said...

Thanks for sharing the post on home maintenance services. Hire the professional handyman service who provides the proper home repair and maintenance services as per the need of clients.

yanmaneee said...

lebron 15
jordan sneakers
kyrie 3
kyrie 4
off white jordan 1
michael kors outlet
adidas yeezy
yeezy shoes
nike react
balenciaga shoes

Cancork Floor INC said...

Handymen are generally hired for the remodeling of home and construction services. Using the acoustic cork wall tiles for your home and to improve high end finishing.

Bilal Shah said...

Thanks for sharing this informational content depthworld

smatha said...

k3h93w7y77 k0d89u5k87 b6r65v9p60 q7j13h3h73 u4k15h4q61 k4d76i5l49