Sunday 28 January 2007

Firemen banned from climbing ladders?

Strange story in press last week about firemen being banned from installing smoke detectors in people's homes as it involves climbing stepladders.

Shock, horror, health & safety gone mad, Daily Mail up in arms, etc. etc. Except there is nothing at all in the Working at Height Regulations that would prevent a fireman climbing a stepladder to install a smoke alarm.

Yet Sean Starbuck, regional chairman of the FBU, is quoted saying:

"The use of stepladders to fit smoke alarms contravenes working-at-height regulations".

This is utter tripe. Was he misquoted? Or has he simply never bothered to find out what the Working at Height Regs actually say?

It wouldn't have taken him, or any of the journalists reporting this story, long to check. The Working at Height Regs have a short section all about ladders, and basically say they are fine as long as they are the most appropriate device for the task (e.g. if risk of fall is low; and task duration is very short). Fitting a smoke detector is certainly a short duration task; and a fireman, who climbs ladders for a living, is probably pretty good at not falling off them.

This sort of thing really gets my goat - and continues to portray the HSE as meddling fools trying to eliminate every possible risk from day-to-day activities, which on the whole they probably aren't. Why do they not rebut this sort of nonsense? Surely they must read the same story? Do they just sit in their offices fuming about how they have been misrepresented again?

OK, I did just find this buried on the HSE's website:

So they did try and rebut it, but clearly without effect. I just Googled a couple of sentences from that rebuttal, and it appears nowhere other than HSE's own site, so I guess no paper bothered to print it. And if they did, would just be on the letters page, not in the news where the original misleading story appeared.

The HSE makes their job so much harder by not effectively challenging this sort of stuff. It's like the "Cry wolf" fable: if you think the HSE is constantly wittering about trivial risks, you won't believe them when they warn you about something that genuinely is dangerous.


Unknown said...

kansas city chiefs jerseys
polo ralph lauren
air jordan shoes
nike air jordan
coach outlet store online
asics sneakers
yeezy boost 350
converse shoes
canada goose uk
polo ralph lauren

miki said...

0815jejeL'économie difficile s'est asics gel lyte 3 femme chausport avérée difficile pour de nombreuses entreprises Stockport, et même des entreprises asics gel kinsei 4 soldes à travers le Grand Manchester. Nike Shox R3-R4 de nike air jordan 11 retro low concord tous réputés ainsi que dans la demande des Asics Gel Kayano Evo Pas Cher noms de marque des clients et de les offrir asics gel lyte 3 femme grise et rose à des frais peu coûteux. Les petites entreprises nike air jordan 13 retro femme fournissent des baskets athlétiques pour diverses actions d'athlétisme new balance lille adresse comme le baseball, le soccer, le tennis, le basketball, air jordan 1 retro mid wb hare le golf, le soccer, la natation et ainsi de suite.

Unknown said...

kd 10
michael kors sale
moncler jackets
goyard tote
kyrie irving shoes
adidas superstar shoes
nhl jerseys
lacoste outlet

yanmaneee said...

nike air max 270
chrome hearts
asics running shoes
golden goose
coach outlet sale
coach outlet
adidas nmd

Safety First Training Ltd said...

You need to get the construction course before working at the construction site. WHMIS Certification training course will help you to work safely at the construction site.

Thomas More said...

Greetings! I'm Thomas, an experienced Assignment Help dedicated to providing you with high-quality and well-referenced papers. Trust me, via Assignment Galaxy, for flawless assignments.